Donate Now!

Evolution – Should we rename the Social Determinants of Health to be the Social Determinants of Equity?

Hello, Aaanin, Boozhoo, Bonjour!

Equity is making headlines now more than ever. At NOSM improving health equity in Northern Ontario has been a priority since the School’s inception; this continues to be a focus in our next strategic plan. We are committed to leading the way with our values of social accountability and inclusiveness and with a culture of respect.

It’s important to note that the root causes of worsening health in entire populations is linked to inequity. Camara Phyllis Jones is research director on social determinants of health and equity in the Division of Adult and Community Health, National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion in Atlanta, Georgia. Dr. Jones is a family physician and epidemiologist whose work focuses on the impact of racism on health and wellbeing. In the US, her work advocates for universal access to high quality health care, but also raises attention to the clear links between the social determinants of health (including poverty) and the social determinants of equity (including racism). I think all physicians would benefit from watching her presentation.

People in highly inequitable circumstances have little choice but to resort to using the health system when they “fall off the cliff.” Usually, in those emergencies, a system kicks in to offer them care. But what about those who have very little access, or no access at all?

In Northern Ontario, accessible health care is a huge problem. We know this. It is why a transformation of health human resources (HHR) planning is the top priority of our 2021-2025 Strategic Plan; a plan that will challenge us in all that we do.

One of the key areas is linking health human resources to Northern Ontario’s needs. NOSM seeks to build a flourishing physician workforce for Northern Ontario; one that is locally integrated within the system, with a strong regional network. Primary care at the foundation, supported by robust, accessible specialist services across the North.

Clinical education must be considered an integral component of a sustainable health-care system. The physician resources required to enable high quality, accessible care must also be considered in the context of teaching and learning. Education must be built into the health-care system; this means learners are trained by the same physicians presently working in the region. By sharing skills and methods through the Northern lens of care we ensure that future physicians are capable of providing the same level of innovative, high-quality care.

The concept of an integrated teaching and clinical service workforce has not been realized in Northern Ontario, but it is the key to the future success of sustainable health-care delivery for the region—a region of complex geography, diminished access to care and higher than average rates of chronic disease, morbidity and mortality.

Despite NOSM’s 12 graduating classes of students, and a total of 714 MD graduates, the needs of Northern Ontario remain high. Rural, remote, Indigenous and Francophone communities still lack family physicians and several communities across Northern Ontario are in crisis. This situation impacts not only clinical care but also NOSM’s ability to sustain the distributed medical education model intended to ensure a future workforce.

Addressing the social determinants of health requires action and effort to reduce health and socioeconomic inequalities. Objections to taking action on the social determinants of health are often intensely political. In response to my statement against racism, some say it is not our responsibility to enforce behaviour. I implore you to consider the facts. Poverty, rising inequality in income and assets, and social exclusion all drive the widening and deepening health inequalities in Northern Ontario.

The Public Health Agency of Canada lists examples of determinants of health from income and social status, race, to gender and culture. The list is extensive and we know the health of any individual is a complex summation of these factors.

NOSM’s new strategic directions will address inequity and the necessary system transformation to align with Ontario Health Teams, supporting seamless, integrated care, better patient outcomes, and better value for funders with more integrated, more cost-effective care. To achieve this, we need adequate local physician resources in communities to decrease system fragility and locum dependence. Ensuring adequate physician resources will be an investment in higher value care in the future.

The system relies on effective recruitment and retention of comprehensive family physician generalists who can work across communities in hospital, long-term care, home care, and primary care in urban and rural environments alike.

Building primary care as the foundation of the health-care system is critical now, as we anticipate another wave of acute COVID-19 cases, and as we anticipate the emergent waves of chronic disease both from COVID-19 and from other complex conditions including increasing mental health and addictions.

The Northern Ontario Health Equity Strategy states that equitable access to physician services is key considering that health outcomes across Northern Ontario are significantly worse than the rest of the province.

As for the social determinants of equity—they are key to revitalizing NOSM’s social accountability mandate. NOSM remains devoted to addressing the needs of vulnerable populations. Our health-care services must address the wider growing crisis by building increased clinical capacity and socially accountable research with findings that will help us formulate realistic solutions. NOSM is prepared to face these challenges.

A new NOSM initiative, led by Dr. Barbara Zelek, NOSM’s new Division Head of Clinical Sciences, will help us understand priorities that matter to Northern Ontario patients, primary health-care professionals, and communities through collaborative research. A Practice-Based Research Network (PBRN) called NORTHH (NOSM Research Toward Health Hub) was developed to workat the intersection of quality improvement and research, to address these critical priorities. Dr. Zelek tells us more about this important initiative in this video. Thank you Dr. Zelek for your passion, dedication and work in addressing the social determinants of health in our region.

Miigwetch, thank you, merci, for individually committing to health equity in Northern Ontario.

Dr. Verma


Please continue to follow my journey on Twitter @ddsv3 using #WhereisDrVerma

I welcome input on this blog and other issues you want to bring to my attention by email to dean@nosm.ca.


Orange Shirt Day is September 30
Orange Shirt Day encourages Canadians to work together towards reconciliation and to hear the truth telling that comes from residential school survivors who have shared their stories. Join me on September 30 at 1:30 p.m. to hear from residential school survivors Donna Debassige and Edmund Metatawabin.

Orange Shirt Day tees are back! Buy yours at the NOSM storeSurvived, still here artwork by Isaac Murdoch.

For more details or to donate to the Indigenous Educational Initiatives and the Indigenous Bursary Fund, visit nosm.ca/orangeshirtday.

→ Email a selfie of you wearing your Orange Shirt to communications@nosm.ca and we will share it on NOSM’s social media!


15th Annual Northern Health Research Conference
This year’s NHRC is going virtual! Join us on Friday, October 2 at 9:00 a.m. with keynote speaker, Dr. Erin Cameron. Learn more at nosm.ca/nhrc.

NOSM ALUMNUS NEW ACADEMIC DIRECTOR, ELECTIVES

The Northern Ontario School of Medicine (NOSM) is pleased to announce Dr. John Coccimiglio has accepted the position of Academic Director, Electives, effective September 1, 2020. Dr. Coccimiglio completed both his MD and family medicine residency at NOSM.

Devoted to living and working in the region, Dr. Coccimiglio now practices as a family physician in acute and long-term care in Thunder Bay. Dr. Coccimiglio has been recognized throughout the years for his academic excellence, clinical teaching, research, and volunteer work. He attributes his achievements and work ethic to the academic and clinical experiences he obtained while a student at NOSM.

With a strong passion for leadership and collaboration, it is with much enthusiasm that Dr. Coccimiglio looks forward to his new role. His responsibilities include overseeing the development, scheduling and ongoing quality improvement of clinical and non-clinical electives across Northern Ontario teaching sites, to support NOSM’s social accountability mandate and support future physician workforce development.

 

The end of Summer: Teaming up for fall

Hello. Bonjour. Aaniin. Boozhoo.

As summer comes to an end and the leaves begin to change, we’re gearing up for yet another academic year. Of course many of us have been working throughout the summer and in fact our post graduate programs have been well into their academic year.  I hope everyone was still able to revel in the smells of sunscreen, bonfires, the lake and camp, fresh fish, and forest air. I have to say that I have never seen such bright sunsets, heard such bounding thunder, nor experienced such brilliant rainbows as I did in Northern Ontario.

To me, the mixed weather is a perfect metaphor for my first two months and mixed expectations of what’s to come with a jam-packed academic year ahead for NOSM. I’m wishing all of you a Happy Labour Day weekend – the last real weekend of summer.

Most physicians do not take too much time off. The majority seem to sprinkle their holidays between the summer and winter, depending upon their tastes. I know quite a few were involved in a new initiative to become one of the Ontario Health Teams, announced by the Ministry of Health a few months ago. Apparently, Ontario Health Teams are being introduced to provide a new way of organizing and delivering health care that will be more connected to patients in their local communities.

Under these teams, it’s expected that all the health-care professionals in hospitals, community settings, clinics, and in long-term care will work together as one coordinated team. Several organizations have come together in the North to apply to become Ontario Health Teams (OHTs) and a small list of teams were invited to provide the full application. The Northern Ontario School of Medicine is involved in many of these applications because our faculty and our sites are part of the regions where health care will be delivered by these teams.

The academic mission, especially that of training physicians, will be an integral part of what happens in these teams. Some teams who are being considered for the full application include: Équipe Santé Sudbury and Districts OHT, Algoma OHT, Near North Health and Wellness OHT, All Nations Health Partners OHT in Kenora, and the Muskoka and Area OHT. A full list is accessible here on the Ontario Health website.  The Canadian Addiction Treatment Centres has also been named as one of the innovative models that will be invited to full application. I am hopeful that many, if not all, will succeed.

This is a very exciting time for Ontario and especially for the North if we, together as a unified group, are able to accomplish all the expectations of an Ontario Health Team. NOSM stands ready through its advocacy strategy and its social accountability mandate to support any or all Ontario Health Teams in our geographic area, and to assist in studying whether this will be an initiative that will improve health care in Northern Ontario.

It’s expected that some of the improvements and integrated health care will fundamentally change how patients will experience the system. If teams are successful with the expectations that have been laid out, there will be much more opportunity to have virtual care and easy access to primary care; plus, navigating the system will be made much more flexible to allow for an open transition between health care providers.

For instance, did you know that the new apps can now read your blood pressure by taking a selfie? Or take an ECG on demand using your smart watch? As we speak, personal health data will be as easy to access as the fitness information on a FitBit.
I have often wondered why the health system is the slowest to evolve. Maybe new OHTs will be the answer?

I’m interested in how you’re going to experience these Ontario Health Teams and what you think about them. Certainly, in my opinion, they will require a significant amount of technology to share information and to provide the kind of advances in health care accessibility that I see coming down the pipeline. Also, I’ll be interested to see whether the funding models will create efficiencies. NOSM will be happy to work with our partners to study their impact and the outcomes for the people of the North.
I’m curious about your opinion. Let me know what you think.

Speaking of team work, I want to send a shout-out to the collaboration of our MD students led by Ben Lafleur (fourth year MD student), and by Dr Lee Toner, Phase 3 (Clerkship) Director and faculty member, that resulted in a 98% response rate by 2019 NOSM graduates to the Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada’s annual Graduation Questionnaire (GQ).

As NOSM’s Senior Director Undergraduate Medical Education, John Friesen says, “Ben brought his positive and collaborative nature to the entire UME student body for the Independent Student’s Assessment which set the stage nicely for the Year 4 students to participate in the 2019 GQ report that we knew would be critical to our UME accreditation visit in April 2020.”

The GQ results are really remarkable and reflect the teamwork of the students, teaching faculty and UME leadership. Your commitment achieved the highest standards of excellence in our MD program. The GQ data released last week by the AFMC shows a major, positive shift in that direction.

By all accounts, the students reported improvements in all areas, especially in accessibility to leadership, in wellness, and with the curriculum. We noted an ongoing issue with career advising and elective choices, to which NOSM is addressing by undertaking several new initiatives. The GQ is a very good measure of the pulse of the medical student experience, and I am delighted to see that, at this time, that experience is good. Thank you to Interim Associate Dean Brian Ross, Senior Director John Friesen, our students and the entire UME team for a job well done! As everyone already knows, we are gearing up for our Accreditation visit next year and this means we are in a good position to do well.


Students, please note: The Dean’s office will be hosting a pub night meet and greet on September 30 at Spacecraft Brewery in Sudbury from 5-7 p.m. Another will be held in Thunder Bay at the Sovereign Room on October 18 from 5-7 p.m. Keep your eye out for a formal invitation.


As usual, you are invited to follow my journey on Twitter @ddsv3 using #WhereisDrVerma. If you have feedback or ideas about how I can better communicate with you, please let me know by emailing me at dean@nosm.ca or by taking a quick survey here at any time.

Also, please help us spread the word about this exciting opportunity: 
The Northern Ontario School of Medicine seeking an Associate Dean, Undergraduate Medical Education to oversee and provide strategic direction for the (UME) program. To learn more information about this exciting role click on this link: Associate Dean – Undergraduate Medical Education

NOSM University